Electrolux JetMaxx vs. Panasonic MC-CG917
I had previously compared the Panasonic MC-CG917 to the MC-CG902, and established the the x917 made a bunch of small improvements over the x902 without regressing in any way, so let's compare this Electrolux JetMaxx to the Panasonic MC-CG917.
Both are very similar bagged canister vacuums with a lot of similar features and design ideas. But each machine has shown me that the other is imperfect. Because I gave the Panasonic five stars, I feel I should do the same for the Electrolux. Here are the pros of each machine:
PROS for ELECTROLUX:
+ Definitely quieter. It may be similar decibel-wise, but from a sones standpoint - the loudness perceived by humans - it is much quieter. This equals less annoyance and less having to turn the television up when someone else is vacuuming. You can basically have a normal conversation over it, especially when the brush roller is not being used or by turning the suction down...
+ ...which is another point...
Comparison of the JetMaxx with the Panasonic Optiflow and Miele midsize
I've been using the same Miele S312 vacuum for about 15 years, and also have a Panasonic MC-CG917 "OptiFlow" Bag Canister Vacuum, so I was happy to get this to compare. I found it to be superior to the other (also HEPA) vacuums in terms of raw rug cleaning power, with a few issues.
* DOES IT SUCK?: In this case, Electrolux lives up to its name. Not only did the vacuum lift crud out of my entry rug that the Miele had missed, it lifted the entry rug. But much of this is the "Power Nozzle" floor tool, which is an appliance in its own right.
* FORM FACTOR: All three of the vacuums consists of a small-ish teardrop-shaped body containing the motor and bag, along with a hose, extendable wand, and various cleaning heads. All three have hoses that do 360-degree rotation. The hose bearing on the Miele is metal (not sure if that's true for the newest models), on the other two it's plastic. The hoses on...
The ultimate vacuum cleaner
I've been a huge Electrolux fan since about 2002 when I bought my first canister model. I bought it from an actual "vacuum cleaner dealership" (are these even around any more??) and paid over $500. It was the most expensive vacuum cleaner I ever bought.
It worked great until about 2009, when my housekeeper vacuumed up some snow and fried the motor.
So I bought another Electrolux, this time a canister model that cost about $300 and lasted until 2012-- when a different housekeeper vacuumed up a wet floor after watering plants. The moral of this story (well, there are probably plenty) is that the Electrolux canister is not a wet-dry vac. In fact, water of any kind seems universally lethal to the canisters.
Anyhow, I bought my third Electrolux green last year and it works just as great as the others. It was significantly cheaper, which you can tell from the construction and weight of plastic-- especially the hose.
This model (my 4th Electrolux),...
Click to Editorial Reviews
No comments:
Post a Comment